to our mailer and receive a free downloadable cookbook with our TOP RECIPES!

Ingredient: M&M's (Red's Picked Out)

Reindeer Nutter Butter Treats

All the other reindeer loved Rudolph, and all your party guests will love these happy little guys. The only thing better than a Nutter Butter is one dipped in chocolate, and these Reindeer will make you even more popular than the red-nosed guy who saved Christmas! Guys, I have a little problem when it comes to peanut butter. I may or may not have a jar stashed under my car seat right now with some disposable spoons. It’s really not my fault, though. It’s hard to abstain when it manages to make its way into sweet and savory dishes! Peanut butter cookies, crisp buttery edges full of sweet peanutty flavor, with the signature sugar-glazed crisscross pattern that makes extra crispy bits on top, yeah, they’re a real weakness. Easy access to something like Nutter Butters at the store has pretty much secured my seat in peanut butter anonymous. I’m here today to lure you over to the brown side too by sharing these seemingly innocent Reindeer Nutter Butter treats. Trust me, you’ll be commiserating with me in my peanut butter coma soon enough! Whether someone first dunked their chocolate in peanut butter or smeared peanut butter all over someone else’s chocolate, you almost always find the rich, dark Aztec contribution to the world whenever there’s peanut butter nearby. We won’t break from that tasty tradition here. You’ll just dip...

Read More

Reindeer Sugar Cookies

 You can skip the fancy cookie cutters for these delightful little deer. They’re made from buttery sugar cookie dough and dressed to impress guests, hostesses, or even a jolly old elf. If you’ve ever been stuck in a big group trying to figure out where to go for dinner you know just how impossible it is to satisfy everyone at once. Decisions can be hard, especially when there are lots of different opinions (and desserts!) to consider, but I’ve never met anyone who doesn’t love a good sugar cookie. They’re simple but full of buttery flavor, with just a...

Read More

Reindeer Oreos

Reindeer Oreos, complete with a shiny red nose, are an easy way to cook up a lot of fun without a lot of cooking. These adorable reindeer might not be able to pull a sleigh, but they’ll make a festive footprint on your holiday baking. Look out! These chocolate treats are about to unseat Rudolph as the most famous reindeer of all. Everyone’s favorite red-nosed reindeer can’t hold a candle to chocolate-covered-Oreos turned into a delightful snack. Just some cookies, candy, and pretzels (or, as I like to call them, the three main food groups) are all you need...

Read More