Cook the pasta (8 ounces) according to package instructions, just until al dente. Rinse pasta and drain well.
Add pasta to a mixing bowl and combine with 1/2 of pickle juice (straight out of the jar). Let sit for 5 minutes and drain.
Mix together all the creamy dill dressing ingredients in a mixing bowl.
Add pasta, cheese (1 cup), pickles (1 cup), dill, and onion (3 tablespoons) to a serving bowl and toss with dressing.
Refrigerate for 4-6 hours for best flavor and serve!
Notes
Pasta: Cooking your pasta al dente takes around 7-9 minutes and means leaving it just a little firm in the center. Follow package directions. Feel free to use different shapes. We really like rotini pasta, too.
Cheese: Switch the cheddar with Colby Jack cheese or pepper Jack.
Pickles: Using sweet pickles instead of dill will create a brand-new flavor profile full of aromatic deliciousness and simple pleasures. My hubby loves this salad made with bread-and-butter pickles! If you like heat, make it with spicy pickles.
Tomatoes: This salad is delicious with tomatoes. I like grape or cherry tomatoes best!
Garlic Powder: Add a tsp or two to the dressing.
Dijon Mustard: This is also a nice addition to the dressing.
Eggs: We like chopped up hard-boiled eggs in the salad as a variation.