American Goulash is a Family Favorite, ONE DISH meal that is perfect any time of year! My family has been making this Goulash for 4 generations!
My Family’s Goulash Recipe:
This is a recipe that has been in my family now for generations. It was handed down to me for my Grandma. I’m always respectful of grandma’s recipes, especially since I know how much love and care she put into the ones she handed down, but I do tweak them occasionally. This old-fashioned goulash recipe, though, is practically sacred, and my family has zero tolerance for any deviation from grandma’s original. Don’t even try to make this goulash recipe with corn or add bell pepper (like the Paula Deen goulash version). You won’t like them when they’re angry!
What is American Goulash?
American Goulash is one of those home-style, comfort food dishes, made in one pot that originated in the mid-west and the south. Made from simple ingredients like ground beef, pasta, and canned tomatoes, it’s easy to fix and makes an equally perfect weeknight meal or potluck dinner. Throughout the country, the name varies depending on the region – Traveling Man’s Hash, Beef and Mac, Slum Gullion, Kentucky Burgoo, and American Chop Suey.
What Ingredients Go Into American Goulash?
You’ll also find that the ingredient list can change as much as the name does. Some recipes have vegetables, some do not. Some have tomatoes, some do not. Some have cheese, some do not. Beef seems to be the only unifying ingredient among the recollected recipes (though some European transplants still make it with pork), but it means “comfort food” no matter who’s doing the answering. This is a simple goulash recipe, one that’s been a family favorite for decades.
American Goulash vs American Chop Suey:
The primary ingredients in these dishes are almost the same. My American Goulash has a stronger, clearer Italian-American influence. If you’d like to try my American Chop Suey recipe, you’ll notice that aromatics are just a little different and include green pepper and the herbs are a combination of Italian spices.
American Goulash vs Hungarian Goulash:
Goulash itself is an old dish created by Hungarian cow herders. The original recipe was a carefully cooked stew, full of tender chunks of beef and onions, with a touch of salt and pepper. Later they added dried chilies from their gardens which gave this dish its characteristic red color.
Most modern Hungarian goulash recipes use a potent (Hungarian) paprika, full of toasted red pepper flavor, to achieve this beautiful hue. Unlike the American versions of goulash which use ground beef, this dish uses large pieces that require a good, slow cook, so an authentic Hungarian recipe will be a baked goulash, simmered slowly in the oven until everything is nice and tender.
American goulash is a respectful homage to the original Hungarian version, with savory ground beef cooked into a rich tomato sauce, full of different herbs and spices depending on which family recipe you’re following. Soft pieces of pasta, usually elbow macaroni, serve as a perfect conduit for all the wonderful flavors in this dish. It’s also a one-pot meal unless you want to throw in a side salad to go along with it, so it’s a home cook’s dream when it comes to clean-up?
How do you make American Goulash?
This is a really easy dish to make! Let me give you a quick summary. The first ingredient, which I’ve already mentioned, is ground chuck, a rich 80/20 ratio with plenty of flavor that cooks much quicker than the original stewed version. I start the recipe by browning the beef. Onions and garlic get incorporated during the browning process too, so they get to absorb some of that beefiness.
The next “standard” ingredient in American Goulash is tomatoes, and that can mean paste or sauce, diced or crushed. Different combinations here can really impact the flavor, and I’m pretty sure you can find recipes for every possible scenario. Grandma’s recipe uses tomato sauce, which adds the thickness you might find in a tomato paste but without the acidic quality that needs to cook down longer to mellow out.
She also calls for diced tomatoes (regular, not petite), which distribute nicely in this chunky dish and adds a slightly subtler tomato flavor than crushed would. (Check out my American Chop Suey recipe if you want a nice strong tomato component. It’s a great hand-me-down recipe from my husband’s side of the family with some overlap in ingredients but a unique flavor all on its own. Oh, and cheese!)
Pasta is definitely a deviation from the Hungarian original, but in American Goulash elbow macaroni is basically a requirement. The size of the pasta itself works great, but the tube-shape means it’ll also hold onto the sauce much better than a flat pasta. In this recipe, the elbows actually cook in the sauce, so they’ll absorb all the wonderful flavors in the dish, rather than just some salted water.
What spices are in Goulash?
My grandma used Mediterranean-inspired spices in her recipe – bay leaves, oregano, and basil. If you don’t have the latter two on hand, you can substitute 1 – 2 tablespoons of Italian seasoning. Grandma also added a touch of soy sauce, which adds a nice, savory umami flavor as well as some salt. You can substitute tamari, the Japanese version of soy sauce, if you need a gluten-free option.
Oh, and speaking of sodium chloride, she also used seasoned salt in this one, rather than just plain table salt. Seasoned salt is a great multi-purpose flavor enhancer to keep on hand for French fries and roasted veggies since it adds spices like paprika and turmeric, onion and garlic powder, and a touch of sugar. All these things work to add another layer of seasoning to this American Goulash.
Reader Tip From Judi: This is always have been the way my grandma made it. Except instead of water, she used tomato juice (which she canned herself)
Dishes Similar to American Goulash:
There are other classic beef and pasta dishes like Cheesy Chili Mac or Beefaroni, but none, in my humble opinion are nearly as delicious as this Goulash. My mom made it for me, and she got the recipe from her mom. Now I get to make it for my family – it’s totally a family thang!
Can You Freeze American Goulash?
So the answer, in this case, is Yes and NO. The pasta in any leftovers of this dish continues to absorb the liquid and it becomes softer and softer. And yes, after freezing and thawing, they’re a bit mushy but, what can I say, I still love Goulash that way! So if you only enjoy a firm al dente pasta, skip the freezing! If pretty soft pasta is still acceptable to you (like it is to me!) you can save part of it in an 8” or 9” pan and freeze it for later
Recipe Notes for American Goulash:
Cheese – So I have to say grandma wouldn’t approve of this addition, but I wouldn’t necessarily discourage making this a cheesy goulash. Frankly, my kids love it with cheese melted on top!
A generous sprinkling of mild cheddar or Monterey jack (even the peppered variety), either stirred in before serving or melting on top, would work well with this dish.
Dietary restrictions – You can easily make this vegetarian by substituting some extra veggies for the beef – about 4 cups of any combination of the following: chopped celery, mushrooms, or zucchini (sautéed with the onions and garlic), or pre-cooked lentils (added during that last 25 minutes).
There are also some great vegetarian “beef” crumbles you can substitute. Gluten-free elbow macaroni works perfectly, if needed.
If you’re looking for a pasta recipe or beef recipe this is it! Or, if you’re like me, and buy your ground beef at Costco, you need lots of good hamburger recipes! This Goulash just may become your go-to recipe. You can always substitute the beef with ground turkey if you want to add to your healthy dinner repertoire.
Now go get your Goulash on!
Old Fashion American Goulash-One Pot Family Favorite
This classic American Goulash is easy, home-style, comfort food! Made in one pot. Perfect for feeding a crowd or hungry family. Loaded with beef and pasta.
Ingredients
- 2 Pounds Ground Beef 80/20
- 1 Large Yellow Onion
- 4 Large Cloves Garlic Minced
- 3 Cups Water
- 2 15 Ounce Canned Tomato Sauce
- 2 14.5 Ounce Canned Diced Tomatoes Juice Included
- 3 Tablespoons Soy Sauce
- 2 Tablespoons Dried Oregano
- 2 Teaspoons Dried Basil
- 2 Dried Bay Leaves
- 1 Tablespoon Seasoned Salt
- 1/2 Teaspoon Black Pepper
- 2 Cups Elbow Macaroni Uncooked
- 2 Cups Cheddar, Shredded
Instructions
In a large pot, brown the meat over medium heat, breaking up the meat as it cooks into small pieces. Continue to cook until the meat is cooked through and there's no longer any pink.
Stir in the onions and garlic. Cook, stirring occasionally, until the onions are translucent.
- Stir in water, tomato sauce, diced tomatoes, soy sauce, oregano, basil, bay leaves, seasoned salt, and black pepper. Bring the mixture to a boil over medium heat. Reduce the heat to low, cover, and simmer 20 minutes, stirring occasionally.
Stir in the pasta, cover, and simmer over low heat, stirring occasionally until the pasta is tender about 25 minutes. Remove from heat, discard bay leaves, and serve!
©GonnaWantSeconds.com. Content and photographs are copyright protected. Sharing of this recipe is both encouraged and appreciated. Copying and/or pasting full recipes to any social media is strictly prohibited.
Nutritional Information
Nutrition information will vary based on the specific products. To be safe, check the nutrition facts labels of your products. Optional object listed above have been left out of nutritional data.
More Easy Family Dinners!
- Porcupine Meatballs ~ These super easy meatballs are made with beef and rice then simmered in a delicious tomato sauce. Always a family favorite!
- Million Dollar Spaghetti ~ This Spaghetti Casserole is super easy to put together and has a center layer of creamy, gooey cheese. This is one of my favorite ways to serve spaghetti and people just can’t get enough of it!
- One Pot Burrito Bowl – This One Pot Burrito Bowl brings the deliciously authentic flavor you’d expect to find in your favorite Mexican restaurant right to your own table!
289 Comments
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
- Low Carb Goulash - Healthy Twist on the Traditional Recipe - […] I stumbled on the perfect low carb vegetables to replace the wheat noodles in my Mom’s famous American Goulash…
- American Goulash | Collector of Recipes - […] For directions, visit Gonna Want Seconds. […]
- 15 $5 Soups & Stews | Minimalist In Manhattan - […] Goulash […]
- Day 310–American Goulash | A Year of Meals - […] I found the recipe here: http://www.gonnawantseconds.com/2012/11/american-goulash/ […]
- American Goulash this is my family recipe! Honestly, its the BEST! Great dinner!!! AmericanGoulash - The Recipe Yummy !! - […] gonnawantseconds.com – Get the recipe […]
- American Goulash this is my family recipe! Honestly, its the BEST! Great dinner!!! AmericanGoulash - KEKO Cooks - […] gonnawantseconds.com – Get the recipe […]
- American Goulash this is my family recipe! Honestly, its the BEST! Great dinner!!! AmericanGoulash Dinner - Food Ziya - […] gonnawantseconds.com – Get the recipe […]
- American Goulash | Bake a Bite - […] Find full recipe at: www.gonnawantseconds.com […]
- American Goulash this is my family recipe! Honestly, its the BEST! Great dinner!!! AmericanGoulash - Also Kitchen - […] Via: gonnawantseconds.com […]
- Amerikanisches Gulasch – oder doch eher Bologneseauflauf? | Zum Nähen in den Keller - […] Pinterest. Veröffentlicht wurde das Original als “American Goulash” von Kathleen von Gonna Want Seconds. Sie schreibt, dass es sich…
- On the Menu: Global Goodness | This is an adventure. - […] afternoon I’m cooking this American Goulash which we’ll have for dinner, but the recipe is so big that we’ll be able…
- TGIF v.4 | She Writes Words - […] favourite meal of the week was this American Goulash recipe I found on Pinterest via Gonna Want Seconds. I’ve been…
- American Goulash | the cooking nurse - […] American Goulash Source: Slightly adapted from Gonna Want Seconds […]
- Secrets to Eating Healthy Post Baby — - […] is a cook once eat twice kind of a meal. I use this recipe. For just Tyler and I…
- Goulash Recipe | Homemade Away From Home - […] found this recipe at Gonna Want Seconds – follow this link for the […]
- American Goulash. This old time classic is amazingly, delicious comfort food! - Where Home Starts - [...] Learn More Here! [...]
- Monday meal plan on Friday | Kimchi Sauerkraut - [...] American goulash. A “newish” recipe that sounds exactly like the stuff I remember devouring from childhood. [...]
Leave a reply
Welcome to Gonna Want Seconds! I’m a home cook and my favorite place to be is in my kitchen cooking up a storm. I’m also a wife, mother, Bernese Mountain dog lover, friend, daughter, sister, and reluctant exerciser. 
Has anyone tried cutting this recipe in half? We’re a family of 5 so I’m not sure I’d want to make so much
I cut in half and it’s just fine.
Hi Jen. Thanks so much for letting us know <3
This is my second time making this. I added a little extra garlic this time. Love it. Easy to make and having leftovers is always great.
Yay Samantha! Extra garlic is always a good idea in my book. I’m so happy you enjoyed the Goulash <3
My mom would make this when I was a kid growing up. But she threw celery in hers. I have to admit that I was not a fan of goulash as a child, probably because it was so bland. Your recipe with the herbs make your goulash anything but bland. When I make this, I add celery as well, usually 2-3 stalks and I buy the diced tomatoes seasoned with basil, garlic and oregano and I use boxed beef broth instead of water for more flavor. I usually leave out the soy sauce and salt because it just doesn’t need it. The beef broth and seasoned diced tomatoes have enough salt. It’s one of my husband’s favorite dishes and I love it too. I especially love how easy it is to throw together and that there are leftovers.
Thanks so much for your kind words, Libby! I love that this is now a dish you enjoy <3
My Grandmother made this . She would look in the refrigator and she what vegetables she had in there. Then she would add then to the Goulash, Absoluately delish.
Thanks, Vivian. Hope you make it too!
This is always have been the way my grandma made it. Except instead of water, she used tomato juice (which she canned herself) I love this and can eat a lot of it!!! Thank you for sharing this recipe
Hey Judi! The tomato juice is absolutely brilliant and I’m going to share that in the article. Thank you so much for sharing with us!
I will make this using vegetarian beef substitute.REcipe sounds deliciou
I think that would be amazingly delicious Dee. My daughter makes a low carb version of this replacing the pasta with shredded cabbage. It’s so yummy that way too <3
Love the American goulash.. great go to recipe in the winter.. anytime really..
Thank you Michelle! I totally agree 🙂
I followed your American Goulash recipe to the “T” (except the store was out of 80/20 ground beef, so I had to get the 90/10 and added a little olive oil while browning), and my husband and I LOVED it! Your recipe will be one of our go-to recipes, especially in the cooler months. I was surprised at some of the ingredients, such as Soy Sauce, but added it to my shopping list anyway. SO glad I did – the combination of flavors is amazing! Thank you for sharing your family recipe with us! 🙂
You’re so welcome Patty! I’m happy you and hubby enjoyed! 🙂
When do u add cheese
Hi Roxanne. At the end, as an optional topping 🙂
You can use low sodium soy sauce. I love adding soy sauce to my pasta recipes.
Great idea Diane! Thanks so much for sharing <3
I always do mine in the crockpot leave on low about half a day while im at school turns out amazing! And dinner is ready!!!!
Great idea Tina!
Do I drain the meat??
Hey Raylyn, no I do not. If you prefer to make this lower in fat, then absolutely, you should drain the meat. I think the fat adds to the flavor and it doesn’t make the dish greasy. And to be totally honest, my Grandma didn’t so, I was taught to make the dish without draining it <3
This is a weekly staple. Always have on hand in fridge, and is a huge hit with any and everyone. Thank you for a simple delicious recipe.
You’re so welcome, Robin. I’m happy you’re enjoying the recipe 🙂
This is by far the best recipe for hamburger and noodles I love it sooooo much that I never want to share. I wouldn’t change a thing on the ingredients everything is flat out amazing! You can never go wrong making this! And everyone In the family LOVES IT
Thank you Bernadette!
I am going to work this out to feed eighty people adults and children for Bible school lunch. Wish me luck!!
Wow! I hope you enjoy Jackie 🙂
We used less tomato sauce, and instead of soy it was worcestershire sauce. A couple cans of pork n beans and a squirt of ketchup. Everything else spot on. It became the kid snack after day 1 dinner. Lots in refer and teens could come home from school and heat up a bowl … Anytime. Mom would make huge pot & freeze some.
Thanks Fiddi 🙂
This was one of the few dishes that my dad was in charge of cooking. He would make the same thing only substitute kidney beans for the macaroni and call it chili:) He’s 89 years old now and I bet he could still make it. He would put the sugar bowl on the table when serving and we would sprinkle it on top!
Hi Viki. I love that story! I’ve never heard of sprinkling it with sugar!
i always add a lil sugar to my spagetti so it would make sense to me to add a lil here
Thanks Desiree. <3
This is delicious! Just finished making it. Thank You
Geri, I’m so glad you enjoyed!
I’m planning to make this for my family this week, and I’m wondering if you’ve had any experience with freezing the leftovers?
Hi Pearl 🙂 Yes,I have frozen this in the past. Honestly, it’s not at it’s best after freezing. The pasta gets very mushy.
I love this recipe, I add corn and tomato paste, the little cans 2, that’s how my mom and grandma taught me. Gonna try the bacon idea, sounds yummy.
Christy, both those additions sound really yummy. I’d love to hear back from you if you try it with bacon! 🙂
I tried with bacon, it is awesome. Quite possibly The Best I have ever made. Yummy!! ????????
First time making american goulash and this is amazing! Thanks for sharing this recipe!
Hi Jessica. You’re so welcome. Glad you liked it 🙂
I don’t know who called this Kentucky But too, but they lied. Has no similarities at all. But this is a good recipe.
Well, good to know. Thanks John 🙂
Very good! I added some Worcestershire.
Stephanie, sounds like a nice addition!
I modified the recipe to serve 60 people at our center. I did a taste test (think that is mandatory) right after it was done. We are having it at lunch today so we will see how it turns out. I have two roaster ovens full. I was wondering if anyone had an idea how long and at what temperature I should reheat it?
Hey Jim I hope the American Goulash is a big hit for you!
I call it “Boy Scout Special” because my Mother was a Boy Scout Mother. On the nights she held the meeting for the Scouts at our home, we had this for supper. So, henceforth to be always called “Boy Scout Special”. That’s a great memory for me so thanks for ‘stirring’ it up!
Great story Jane. Thanks for sharing it 😉
i found this recipe via Pinterest and just had to tell you how much my family loves it! It has become a “frequent flyer” on my recipe rotation! Thank you for sharing it!
You’re welcome Kelly! It’s a huge it in our family too!
The perfect Goulash recipe, delicious! I halved the recipe and it was perfect for 2, with leftovers. Would be enough for 4 people!
Thanks so much Wayne!
Almost forgot we are from rural Wisconsin
My Mom made hers a little different. In a large pot she cooked 4 cups of elbow macaroni.She would fry 2 lbs of hamburger After it started to brown she would add a large onion cut up rather coarsely. Everything would be combined in a large enamel roaster with a qt of whole tomatoes and a qt of tomato sauce. Then bake for about half an hour or so. Some of us would put Parmesan cheese on top but all of us would eat with homemade bread and butter. She called hers American Goulash.
Sounds delicious Brian 🙂
This was good! I never would have thought to put soy sauce in a tomato based dish, but it was the perfect blend of seasoning. I only used about a tbsp of oregano because I didn’t realize my jar was almost empty.
Also, I had to use miniature penne pasta because there was no elbow macaroni at the store. I’m assuming it is because I shopped on July 4th and macaroni salad is popular for holiday BBQs so they were sold out. Nonetheless the miniature penne was very good.
I will definitely make this again.
Hi Pam. I’m so glad you enjoyed the American Goulash 🙂 The mini penne sounds like a really great solution!
So I am 14, and I was looking for simple recipes to make for supper & came across this one! After I read some great comments, I decided to try it out! At the moment it’s cooking, & it smells delicious, I can’t wait to try it!
Hi there Annie! I’m so excited to hear from you. Thanks for connecting. I hope you enjoy the American Goulash. It’s been a family fav for generations 😉
I know that your reply was made 3 years ago, and you may never see this, but if you do, I just wanted to commend you for cooking at 14. Most kids today at that age can’t even boil water. I hope that you continued to expand your cooking skills and enjoy the dishes you make.
This is known as American Chop Suey in New England, and made the same way basically… I used to make it for my kids all the time. One of their favorite ways was to add in Velveeta cheese chunks that melt into it and give it an amazing flavor. Doesn’t look so pretty, but man, does it taste good! Another thing I do is add a can of Ro-tel tomatoes (the mild ones) in the mix and we really enjoy that too… Kicks it up a notch… Always served with bread and butter here at the house!
Hi Linda! We always ate this with bread and butter at are house growing up as well! I’ve never tried it with Velveeta….Great idea! 🙂
i love this recipe:)thank you!i didn’t grow up on goulash,but my kids are!they love it and so do i:)thanks so much for such an easy to put together,budget friendly,nutritious meal.also,there must be some kind of ancient wisdom in this recipe because my noodles aalways come out mushy when i make them in the dish,but in this,they are always just right!
xoxox
Hey Liz! I’m with you! I love a little bit of mushiness in the noodles in this recipe! LOL! So glad this recipe is becoming a new family tradition for you!
I have a concoction just like yours and the kids always loved it! It was one of my soccer night stove top staples. I had another Mexican style one using rice that I threw together. I had never written up a recipe and, as luck would have it, they were the first “recipes” my college age daughter called home for 😉
Hi Wanda. Isn’t that just the way of it! One of the main reasons I started this blog was because I never used to measure anything or write out recipes and when my kids asked me for a recipe I was lost! I hope my recipe is close to what you used to make 🙂
Gorgeous Goulash–looks so hearty and good!
Hi Rachel. Thank you hope you give it a try 🙂
I am glad you called this American Goulash as this is not a true goulash which comes from Hungry. I grew up on your kind of goulash and my husband grew up calling it slop.
Hey Laurie. I guess whatever you call it this dish is still yummy 🙂
I never realized goulash was just pasta with meat sauce. I thought it was some exotic dish. I make this all the time without the soy sauce.
Hi Kathleen too funny! Nothing exotic at all 🙂
Hi Kathleen, I’ve made this for years, with very different ingredients than you seem to use. Your’s sure does sound good though, and I’ll have to try it that way.
I usually use ground beef, chopped onion, garlic, salt, pepper, chili powder, stewed tomatoes-chopped up, kidney beans, and elbow macaroni. I drain the fat off the meat and onion before adding other ingredients and boil my macaroni and drain it and add it to the meat mixture about 5-10 minutes before serving. Add some bread and butter and a salad, what a great meal. If you need a little more liquid, add some tomato sauce or water to the mixture. A little sugar to it to cut the acidity.
Hi Darla. Thanks for sharing your version of this goulash! I think a lot of people add kidney beans. Funny my family never did!
1 tablespoon of seasoned salt sure sounds like A LOT, considering the soy sauce, canned tomatoes, etc. Is that the correct amount of seasoned salt? I plan to try this recipe soon! Thanks.
Hi Leanne. That’s how much I use when I make this recipe. Remember seasoned salt has other ingredients so it’s not the same as 1 tablespoon of salt. A lot of my readers have made the recipe and no one has said they felt it was too salty. All that said, it’s very easy to cut the salt back and add more if you’d like. Everyone likes food seasoned a bit differently. Hope that helps 🙂
Family favorite! we do add a few more items, corn, green an red peppers, sliced olives, sometimes we add chili {homemade or canned } tomato soup, worcestershire an cheese, this makes it go farther too if you have to feed a lot. I cook macaroni separate an add last an simmer a few minutes an sometimes we use mac an cheese.
Hey Sharon. Wow! Sounds like some great additions!
I love my mothers Goulash, But one of the best Things was the Fresh bread with butter that we dunked in the tomato sauce, each one of us kids would eat 3-4 slices of Bread…….Yummy
I love my goulash with bread and butter as well! Doesn’t get better than that!
Hey Kathleen, this is my 2nd time making this great stuff. My question is.. When I lower the heat to low after coming to a boil and let the goulash simmer for 20 min. it continues to boil the entire time. Is this the way it is supposed to work? I use an electric stove so maybe that is why? Also boils the entire time simmering after adding the elbows. It still tastes great just wondering if this is the norm. Thanks, Jim
Hi Jim. It sounds like your cook top runs a bit hotter than mine. I keep mine at a simmer not a boil. You might need to adjust the length of time simmering and watch for sticking or too much evaporation.
everyone always list how many it will serve.
I would like to know many pints/quarts of sauce it makes because I’d like to can the sauce. I cook and can by the 18 quart batch how would I ramp this up
Hello Rick. This recipe serves 8-10 people. I’m sorry I don’t know how many pint’s/quarts it makes.
Zsuzstyina,
Semantics Simply the set of associations that a word evokes, is the meaning of a word defined by the images that its users connect to it?
The images on this page evoke goulash to me. And its very good goulash to boot.
Hi!
Sorry, but this isn’t gulyás, what you mean is Pörkölt. Gulyás is a soup.
Will you marry me? This was very good!! My wife is the type that don’t like onions, just has ketchup on her burgers.
So I made this big ole batch for basically just me to take to work and chow on for a few days.
I did get her to try a bowl and she did like it but picked out the tomatoes and said she would drain the fat out of the hamburger cuz its kinda greasy, I told her to make a batch for herself cuz I love this stuff.the way it is. Thanks for the recipe.
Hi Jim. So glad you liked this recipe! Thanks for your feedback. You’re too funny 🙂
Hey, Kathleen!
I made this for my monthly “in-laws” & parents dinner. It was a HIT! My husband raved about this goulash (it was better than his moms!) 🙂
And they were also delicious leftovers.
I have added it to my “Dinner rotation” Pinterest board. I make a side dish and a main dish once a week from that board. This is a main dish I will be making at least once a month, a staple in our home! Thanks for the great dish, Kathleen.
Hey Kat! So glad you liked the recipe! Happy it made your dinner rotation!!!
Tomorrow, Christmas Eve, is my birthday and I’m giving myself a pot of this memory making dish for my present to myself. My mom made a similar version. She would bring the water to a boil and then pinch in the raw hamburger meat and chopped onions. Then as the fat rose to the top, she would skim off the “scum” with a large metal spoon. So we always called it Scum Gullion, or just plain “scum” ! Her secret ingredient was a T. of bacon grease. Happy Birthday to me!
Hope you have a glorious birthday Proud Mary 😉
This brings me back to H.S. in the 60’s. We had this alot, and they served it with green beans on the side. My mouth just waters thinking of it! I’ve tried making it myself a few times over the past 45 plus years, all efforts bombed! Now reading your recipe, I can see why. In New England, we call it American Chop Suey, and a lot of casual restaurants have this on their menu. Now I’ll be able to have this whenever I want! Thank you for sharing.
You so welcome Mary. Enjoy 😉
We make it with the addition of kidney beans. Mom always made this over the campfire on campouts. Great, now I’m hungry!
Bet the campfire added an extra smokiness to the goulash. Yum!
Made this tonight, used your recipe as my base, but added corn, mushrooms, diced green peppers, and a couple pinches of salt… So delicious! Rivials that I ate during my childhood. LOL Thanks!
*SUGAR, D’OH. Typo, sorry.
Deege, so glad you liked it! Great idea to make it your own!!!!
Thank you so much for this recipe! I followed it exactly, with the exception of a few fresh green bean, and it was amazing! I was hoping to have leftovers, but as it turned out I ended up sharing with my sister and my son that popped in for a visit. I couldn’t let them miss out! This is the first time I have ever been compelled to share a review. Don’t miss out! It’s so good and easy to make! Thanks again
Thanks so much Elizabeth for sharing your review, I really appreciate it! Hope to see you on the site again soon 🙂
My mom also made this for us every halloween eve, and served it to us in individual hollowed out sugar pumpkins before we went trick or treating! It is like a hug from home whenever i make it now. I will try adding the soy sauce this year- the only difference in our recipes! Thanks for sharing the love! Xoxo
Hi Bren. That is so such a great story. I love the idea of serving it in a little pumpkin!
I have made this a few times and we love it… but I wasn’t thinking and I cooked the macaroni today thinking that I would save myself some time later (making supper for a crowd) and now I realized I screwed up. And I am out of macaroni. Should I still add the 3 cups of water? I was thinking if I just added the pasta last and didn’t add any of the extra liquid (drain the tomatoes, don’t add any water, etc.) that I would be ok. Your thoughts? Help!
Hi Annie. Well, hmmm. I would start with 1 1/2 cups water because you want the goulash to have some sauce. You can add more as needed. If you feel it’s too liquidy, simmer it uncovered before adding the pasta so some of the liquid evaporates. Let me know how it works out!
I love this recipe. I made it last week, and I’m making it again today. If anyone’s worried about too much oregano, don’t be. It’s perfect. The only things I do differently is 1) the addition of some diced bell peppers – can’t resist – tasty and makes it look a bit more appealing. And 2) I cook the pasta separately (do not add salt to the cooking water if you do this way!) because it absorbs too much of the liquid and when you reheat it, you have mushy pasta, which is not very appetizing. I like to add it about 5 minutes before serving. It’s a keeper! Wish I had this recipe when my kids were growing up.
Thank you Mari! Love hearing how you prepare it 😉
I made this tonight and it was super delicious! Thank you for sharing.
^_^
Thank you Melissa 🙂
Have you ever tried freezing this? I’ve been trying to freeze a meal portion of any meal that I think will work so that my hubby and I don’t die if I forget to cook something….???
Hi Alli, well if you freeze it the pasta gets really mushy.
If you want to freeze, divide in freezer portion before adding pasta. Then cook pasta in defrosted portion and serve.
Thanks Linda 🙂
Hi – mom used to make this when I was a kid and I’ve asked her over and over for the recipe and she doesn’t remember making it! Thanks!
Hey Tina. Well, I hope it taste like your Moms 🙂
This and Corn Bread and Cheddar Cheese …. to die for! Thanks for posting
Roxie, it’s my pleasure 🙂
I made this yesterday and ate it the same day and it was very good! Then I had leftovers today and it really did make a difference waiting over night. Definitely a keeper. My mom would mix in mozzarella and bake it and called it, “more” because all six of us kids would ask for seconds!
Hi Jeanne, my son LOVES this with cheese too! So glad you liked this 😉
My mom made this for me for the first time when I was six years old. She cut the recipe out of the Houston Chronicle newspaper and made it to tempt my appetite because I was sick.
It quickly became a family “go to”, and favorite!
Mom used Worcestershire Sauce instead of Soy Sauce, but otherwise, this sounds just like hers. I will have to try it with the Soy Sauce now to see which one we like best.
Hey Lori. Love to hear that. This recipe is so personal! Worcestershire makes a lot of sense!
Did the recipe for goulash really mean 2
Tablespoons of oregano?
I always use 2 Tablespoons of Oregano. It is not a typo. If you prefer you can use 2 Tablespoon Italian Seasoning and skip the 2 teapoons basil.
My dad used to make something similar to this but he called his “splat” 😛 and if I remember right he added cheese. This looks yummy though I’ll have to try it!
Thank you Lauren. My son always adds cheese to his as well 😉
Hi, I call this goulosh and I thought I made this up until I came across this recipe! I also add grape jelly and ketchup! Hey, don’t knock it until you try it!
Tina, actually sounds interesting!
This was fantastic! I used all the ingredients you mentioned, plus I added Cajun seasoning, chili powder, and a little bit of bacon. Also, I cooked the noddles in chicken broth. It was delicious. I have made different versions of this before, but the soy sauce was new to me. It is the KEY to it though. SO GOOD! It’s 90 degrees out so I am just gonna turn my air way down so I can enjoy this all day haha.
So glad you made this and enjoyed it! Thank heavens for AC!!! LOL
EXACTLY a recipe for goulash I’ve been looking years for….simple ingredients but very flavorful! Thank you!!
Janel, you are sooo welcome. Enjoy 😉
I’m making this right now. It is simmering on the stove as I type. I can’t wait to try it. Don’t really like having to wait until tomorrow but I inderstand the flavor will be much richer and savorful. Thanks for posting. I love comfort food.
Glad to hear it Peggy!
I grew up in the 50s-60s. My grandmother, who lived with us, made this frequently since it is a great meal to stretch the food budget. She called it “Cowboy Chow” and added stewed tomatoes instead of spices. I now make it for my grandchildren who also LOVE it. Thanks for sharing.
gpete, thanks for sharing your story. I love hearing them!
My mom and grandma both made this dish. Mom made it with bacon. In Iowa We called it slumgallion. I’m making it for dinner tonight! Thanks for sharing your recipe.:)
Sherri, You are so welcome! Now I can’t wait to try it with bacon!!!!
This is a good recipe,THEN, we added 1 can of tomato soup ( with out the water) now it is wonderful. and with melted cheese, up another notch.
I grew up in central Ohio, and everyone called this dish “Johnny Marzetti”. My mom made it with tomato paste instead of sauce, and with no oregano or soy sauce. She also added a bit of sugar. Delicious!
Judy, I’ve never heard it called that! Thanks for telling me 🙂
Thanks so much for this recipe, it reminds me so much of my Moms that I’m always trying to make but never get it right. Great recipe! and thanks again.
Hi Randy! You’re so welcome. Let me know if you give the recipe a try 🙂
I made the American goulash. Followed the recipe to a T.. I found it had way to much oregano. Next time I will use half the amount recommended
Do the noodles need to be cooked first when adding it into dish??
Hi Synthia, no I add them uncooked to the dish 🙂
Not to upset your “tradition” with your family recipe but this is only version I have ever seen before and only one my family will eat also (it is my “go to” meal that is very quick and makes great leftovers and lunches):
1 lb. Ground Chuck, browned and drained
1/2 cup or more to tasted diced onions, browned with meat
1 large can undrained whole tomatoes
1 Medium can undrained Ranch Style Beans
2 cups cooked elbow macaroni (I use small elbows but use whatever size elbows you prefer.
1 tsp. (or to taste) Chili Powder
Salt and Pepper to taste
In separate pan cook macaroni to al dente in boiling salted water, drain, set aside.
In Dutch oven Brown Ground Chuck and onion, drain.
Add Ranch Style Beans with juice and tomatoes. With your fingers or knife mash tomatoes.
Add chili powder, salt and pepper.
Add drained macaroni to meat mixture in Dutch oven with ~1/2 cup water. Stir well, cover and simmer for 10 minutes over low heat. Do not overcook. We do not care for the macaroni to be torn!
Serve with bread of your choice and salad of your choice.
Thank you for sharing your family recipe DP Girl 😉
Do we not drain off the excess fat?
Hi Marta, No I don’t drain it. I really like the flavor it adds. Please feel free to drain it if you don’t want the extra fat. It will still be delicious and a bit healthier too! 🙂
Hi,
Don’t the noodles expand overtime and get big and mushy?
Thank you,
Jodi
Hi Jodi, yes they do. If you like your pasta al dente skip the overnight step. It will still be delicious 🙂
I made this goulash a few nights ago and I have to say this was the best goulash I have ever had! I took some of the leftovers and put it in a small baking dish, sprinkled some fresh Mozzarella cheese over the top and baked it until the cheese was bubbly. Served it with some garlic bread and HELLO! Great, great supper. Thanks for the recipe!
Ken Im so so glad you liked it! Thanks for sharing your experience with me!
There is no mention of draining the meat of its grease. Should the onions and garlic be thrown into the grease?
Hi Danielle. Yes, I cook the onions and garlic in the fat rendered from the ground beef. I don’t drain it 🙂
My Mom called this American Chow Mein. She also made something similar using Italian sausage sliced into pieces and Chef Boyardee with mushroom. Any hints on what else is in this would be helpful.
I am making this right now, can’t wait to try your version of it. 🙂
I’m making this recipe right now and it smells AMAZING! This is perfect for me because I work overnights so I can put it together before work and throw it in the fridge to have when I get home. It reminds me so much of my grandfather’s goulash. Thanks for this awesome recipe!
My step dad taught me to make this when I was young. We loved it served on mashed potatoes. It is delish that way! I for one must eat it on the day it’s made. I hate mushy macaroni! My sister & I would also make it with no burger. Yep, just macaroni & tomatoes. Thank you for reminding me of this. I will have to make it real soon.
This was almost exactly my mom’s recipe, minus the soy sauce. I have added corn to it and it didn’t go over well with the family. LOL I just leave it plain ol goulash!
Turned out great! I was trying to replicate my Mother’s version, and your recipe confirmed I was on the right track. I cooked the macaroni first, then added it to the tomato concoction. I also added a can of tomato paste. I did drain the grease, but then added maybe 1/3 back in for flavor. Also added a couple other spice blends, and skipped the soy. My Dad said it was really good, just like my Mom’s!!
Love it! I add potato chunks and corn
Ugh! Been wanting this dish for ages and was super excited to try but the pasta was super soft/mushy. I wouldn’t recommend cooking the pasta for 25 minutes. If I make again I’ll probably cook the pasta separate. I added green bell pepper, one fresh bay leaf and fresh basil to taste.
This stuff is amazing. On my second batch I replaced one cup of water with an additional can of tomato sauce. It made it more ‘creamy’. Very delicious.
This recipe was delicious. I also added a bit of shredded cheese to the top when I served it!
My mother made this with green pepper also–she was from a big family–but it was just her and i–when she made it there was left overs for days–it was great reheated–seems like there was always goulash in the ice box–I was raised on goulash and bread and butter
Thanks for the recipe.. Made it once and now again tonight. It was great, but question – when you said 2 cups of macaroni – do you measure out two cups, or use the whole package of 16 oz (2 cups)… There is a big difference – so just wanted your input.
Thanks Again!
Hey Sandy! Great question. I measured out 2 cups. 🙂
I used this recipe once before and I am getting ready to make it again. It was delicious! I wouldn’t add or substitute anything. Thanks for sharing. P.S. I am the youngest of 9, and we ate a lot of goulash growing up. Half of us kids consider goulash to be comfort food, and love it…..and the other half never want to eat it again!
My sister used to make goulash but never had a recipe and try as I might I could never duplicate hers. I’m cooking at this moment and hope this will be as good as hers, so far it smells and looks delicious. I let you know how it is later. Thanks.
My mom would add a can of red beans to it.
very good
What if I don’t have bay leaves? Will it still be ok without?
Just made it for dinner, and boy was it good.
Sure glad this was on pin. Might try with the green
peppers and mexi-corn. Thank you for sharing a
great meal.
god bless America!!!
Very very similar recipe to my grandmother’s. She too added green (Bell) peppers. We always ate it over cornbread. I am drooling just thinking about it. Thanks for sharing.
I’ve got it on the stove now and it smells amazing! When you reheat the next day, do you just out it back in Dutch oven or other pot and heat on the stove? Do you have to add any water to liquid a bit?
Can’t wait to eat!
This is the same recipe as Bobby’s Goulash on the Paula Deen site other than she makes a “House” seasoning that is used and uses italian seasoning in place of oregano & basil. Very good recipe but I always cut back on the salt & let the diners add more if wanted.
Making this right now…it seems like there is too much liquid and it will have a soup like texture to it. Does the liquid thicken during cooking?
I add peppers, corn and kidney beans. The way my grandpa used to make it 🙂
Can’t wait to try your version of Goulash! Ours is similar to yours but we put about a half cup of halved small green olives which is so amazingly delish! I love facing skeptic’s with this and winning them over LOL!
This was one of my favorite recipes of my grandmas. Have this simmering now and cannot wait to have some tonight. Sorry no waiting
Looks wonderful. I really love beef stews that are hearty. I have to say I never eat it with noodles nor pasta. Sometimes I make them with vegetables and potatoes, and sometimes meant to be served with rice. I just made a goulash that’s just 400 calories per generous serving and it was just amazingly good. You can check my blog if you are interested.
http://healthyroadadventures.blogspot.com/2013/10/goulash.html
My mom used to make chili and put macaroni in it. It’s sort of similar but I’m trying this because it looks so good. Funny, how our childhood memories take us back to food we love <3
Love this recipe! It has been a monthly staple for the past 6 months. Only changes that I made is to cook the beef, onions and garlic at the same time and I always drain the fat after the meat is cooked. We also eat it the same day I make it. Thank you for this yummy recipe 🙂
My Grandma made this when I was young…instead of soy sauce she added a little brown sugar… it was YUMMY!
We have a similar recipe in my family that my grandmother always made. Mostly because it made enough to feed her large family (8) and it was cheap. Ours is tomato soup, elbow macaroni, corned beef, corn, potatoes and rumor has it, cabbage. I never add the cabbage and I prefer to skip the potatoes, We like to crumble up sweet cornbread in it. And it always tasted better as leftovers.
thats gooooooolash on a budget for sure. add alittle rice and youd have my entire kitchen!! god bless america!!
That actually sounds really good with the potatoes for me!
Had this for dinner tonight it’s yummy. My 2 year had three small helping 🙂
Do you drain the fat from the hamberger?
No I don’t 🙂
Hi, I want to make goulosh tonight for dinner so I went to Pinterest and somehow I found yours it sounds really good cant wait to try it but what I wanted to know was do you have to cook your macaroni in the sauce ….if so do the noodles get to over cooked or not please let me know…thank you
My mom made this when I was growing up because it was cheap, she passed away and I never thought to get the recipe. This is as close as it gets, on my way to the store now to make for dinner tonight. Cannot wait!
This was great!! I actually thought it tasted great the same day, but the leftovers were good too.
I just made this. Hope it’s “good” by tonight.
I do almost as the recipe says, but I do add chilli powder to give it the extra zing…we like it hot.
Do you have an approximate serving size for this dish?
Thanks!
-Haley
I haven’t had this in forever and can’t wait to try it out now that I am married to see how it comes out. But being from Kentucky, I can tell you that goulosh and burgoo are totally different things. However, if you have never had burgoo, you may also want to give it whirl. Check out Old Hickory BBQ or Moonlite BBQ, both in Owensboro, KY. Thanks!
Jamie you are so right about goulash and burgoo being two totally different things! And burgoo takes a long time to fix. 🙂 But boy is it good!
This was sooo good! I halved the recipe and had plenty of yummy leftovers. Added half of green pepper. Will be making this again.
2 thumbs up for all versions of Goulash! Mom fed 7 kids on a blue collar budget with 75% of our groceries home grown, traded or hunted. Our version would have to start with home canned tomatoes & elbow Mac, but whatever we had in freezer or was on sale went in the pot. Even venison burger or ground pork browned with onions & celery works if hamburg isn’t on hand. Had to laugh about letting it ‘age’ overnight. We didn’t ever have leftovers& no one who smelled it who didn’t reach for a bowlfull. Thanks for enlightening the rest of humanity what is probably rural white soul food. 🙂
Same with our family, too, Beth. Mama fed seven kids delicious food, and there was always plenty, and almost never any leftovers.
I am making this right as I type and my apartment smells divine. The only thing I am concerned with, is if the pasta will absorb too much of the liquid and become mushy. I have had this problem when I make soups and add pasta or rice. I’m thinking of making the pasta on the side and add it as I eat it.
Thank you!
I just responded to another reader regarding the mushy issue so check that out. If you are going to reheating it multiple times it could totally get mushy. Making the pasta on the side is a fail safe alternative. I just have to say that when the pasta does sit overnight, it does get softer, but it also increases the pastas flavor. I may just be used to the softer texture of the pasta in this dish because that’s how my family made it! Hope that helps….let me know how it works out. 🙂
Well for me…..I separated it into 2-baking dishes and froze 1 and put the other in the refrigerator. I took it out of the refrigerator about 1hr before my cooking time and the put it in a 350 Oven for about 45-min. I was surprised it took so long to heat through but it did and my guys loved it so it was worth the wait
I think it’s much quicker to heat it on the stove top gently.
I did not see how long to cook it after it has been in refrigerator.
I am thinking that I should take it out for about 1hr to bring to room temp. Then what??
I’ve never timed it but I think it takes about 15-20 minutes on a low gentle heat. If it seems a bit dry add a little water so it doesn’t stick to the pan.
My Family and I really enjoyed this recipe. i have one question my noodles ended up being mushy, is that normal? Did I do something wrong? Any advice would be helpful. Thank you
Hmmm. I don’t know why but I don’t seem to have that problem when I make it as directed and I HATE mushy pasta!!! I have had that problem happen when I’ve cooked it the nite before and tried to “keep” it heated for an extended period in a crock pot the next day. Making it the way directed above does definitely make the pasta soft but I haven’t had it turn mushy.
I’m wondering if possibly you let it sit an extended period after cooling? Or maybe the next day? Not sure… You could always cook it for less time or not at all after you add the pasta. You could just keep the pasta out and add it the next day and eat as soon as it’s al dente. Hopefully, this helps a bit and doesn’t just muddy the waters. Let me know if you figure out how to make it work better for you!! Good luck 🙂
I just made this for the second time tonight, and the weirdest thing is that my noodles this time are completely mushy the same day I cooked it. (they held their shape but have the consistency of mush) The only thing I changed between the first time and this was my pasta shape — from medium-sized (De Cecco) to tiny elbows (Panzani). Such a bummer, I’ll defnitely go back to a bigger shape and back to De Cecco.
Do you drain the diced tomatoes?
No, I add everything in the can.
This may be a silly question, but how to you heat it up after it spends the night in the fridge?
Hi Samantha! What a great question!!! You can microwave it or add a little water to a pan and slowly, over low heat, stirring often, heat it until it’s warm through.
Thanks a million Kathleen! My whole family watched me make this yesterday and we are all looking forward to chowing down on it for dinner tonight 🙂
Thank you!
I grew up in Iowa and my mother made this every week. She used home canned tomatoes, and never wrote the recipe down. I got homesick just reading your recipe. I have everything in house, so guess what is for dinner tomorrow?
My mom added just a touch of sugar and we called it slop.
My grandmother always added a couple ribs of chopped celery with the onion and garlic. It’s a secret ingredient that you wouldn’t think adds much, but it really does! 🙂
Hi Kathleen! This recipe looks amazing! I was considering making this tonight. But, I was wondering..Is the Soy Sauce an absolutely necessary element to the recipe? I don’t seem to have any more on hand and no time to pick any up. Is this something I can substitute or leave out altogether without compromising the flavor of the original recipe? If so, what would be an acceptable substitute for this item? Thanks in advance for your help! 🙂
Hey Christi,
This is one of those recipes that I wouldn’t dream of substituting anything. I have a very specific taste memory for this dish and think any change would ruin it for me. That being said, since you haven’t eaten this specific recipe many times it may be fine if you sub the soy sauce for Worcestershire sauce. I’d add 1 tablespoon of the Worcestershire. Btw-I too often need to make substitues but this one kills me a little. I want it to be perfect for you!
Hey Kathleen,
Thank you so much for your suggestions! You’ll be happy and relieved to know that I, in fact did not have to substitute anything in the recipe last night! Haha 🙂
My other half brought me a bottle of Soy Sauce yesterday evening on the way home from work. Needless to say, it came out perfect and tasted amazing! It was a huge hit with the fam! Thank you! 😉
I made this the other day. It was yummy. One pot meal. Love that.
I used a dutch oven.
I have eaten this my whole life, when you grow up poor and in a big family you eat a lot of stew type stuff. I dont have a recipe, i cook my onions and garlic then add in my ground beef, i boil the noodles till theyre al dente while i do the meat. I drain the noodles, put them back in the pot then add the meat, then i put in a huge can of stewed tomatoes that i crush up w a masher, and a can of crushed tomatoes thats like a thick sauce, then add in a couple cans of tomato sauce, some sea salt, garlic powder, onion powder and fresh ground pepper and a bay leaf. I let it simmer until the noodles soak up the sauce some. We then eat it with some buttered bread. No bacon, no soy sauce and the only cheese we use and is a must is shaker parmesan cheese. Its simple, yummy and takes no thinking lol
Kathleen,
You have a winner here. My husband who also loves to cook was very skeptical that this recipe was going to taste good. He asked that I not put the bay leaf in so I didn’t but only to appease him. Guess what? Winner!!!! With or without the bay leaf! Delicious!!!
Thank you for sharing!
Maria
Yay! So happy you guys liked it and made it your own 🙂
Made this for the fam tonight. (I read the part of letting it sit overnoght too late) It was still very good! Everyone liked it, including my picky boys I can’t wait ti see if the leftovers taste better after being refrigerated overnight. The only thing I did different was use ground venison instead of ground beef. Thanks so much for the recipe. It’s a keeper!! 🙂
Karrina, sooo happy it was a hit with the fam! Nothing better than a happy, well fed family 🙂
My father in law use to make this all the time and of course he loved to cook and never shared his recipe. After he passed we searched through all of his books and could never find this recipe. We had many failed attempts until I saw this one Pinterest and decided to try it! It smelt so good I couldn’t wait until the next day to try it!!! And I must say this is the it! I’m so happy to have found this recipe thanks so much for sharing!
Ashley thank you so much for sharing that with me! I’m so happy this recipe connects with your father in laws 🙂
Made this quite a few times now after finding the recipe on Pinterest. Delicious! Thnk you for sharing.
I’m making this as I type, it’s almost finished minus the letting it sit overnight. I kept messing up, but let’s hope it turns out anyway. However it tastes, my kitchen smells delicious!
This is my favorite comfort food of ALL time. My Mom would boil the onions in the water until soft, them crumble in the hamburger meat into the boiling water. Then she would “skim” off the foam (like you do with chicken stock). Then she would add all the tomatoes and sauces. She also added a teaspoon or two of bacon grease. If you are from the South, this makes perfect sense! Add the elbow macaroni and enjoy with saltine crackers. Ahh! The taste of home!
This was great (American Goulash)
So excited to taste this tomorrow as I drool watching it simmer right now! I used paste converted to sauce and diced tomatoes in Italian Seasoning, both bought on accident, but it smells soooo yummy! Comfort food for chilly January MN weather!
I wish I had a big pot of this waiting for me!!! Hope you enjoy 🙂
I love that your recipes come from your granma and your mom. We make a version of goulash at the deli I work at. In addition to bell pepper, we used Spicey V-8 for the tomato sauce. People love it, but I prefer the old standard. Thanks.
So glad I saw this (Pinterest!)! My mom always made “Goulash” for us growing up. It was a recipe she learned from her mom and we never knew anyone else who made it like this instead of the traditional Hungarian way. Our version is slightly different, though: ground beef, green bell pepper, onion, garlic, tomato PASTE, water, basil, oregano and shells instead of elbows. And it’s a sacred recipe in our family, too. So simple and so good! Nice to know we’re not alone anymore. 🙂
Hi I’m actually making this for dinner but after I read your comment about it being better overnight I think I’m going to do that. Do you have a particular time frame as far as leaving in the fridge overnight. I know I will have to let it cool before I put it in the fridge. Or do you think it’s possible that I could make it this morning and Stick it in the fridge and have it for dinner tonight. Either way I can’t wait to see how this turns out. Thanks for sharing!
Hey Amy. Ultimately, I think it’s better overnight when you have the time. It’s totally possible to make it the morning of, but the overnight in the fridge really does something extra for it. When you make it the day before it also becomes a little thicker because the pasta absorbs some of the sauce. If you want you can always add a little water or low sodium beef broth to loosen it up a bit. Low sodium is a must in this case. You really can’t go wrong with this dish! I hope you enjoy it!!!
what if i dont have a dutch oven?
You really just need a large, heavy bottom pan that will accommodate all the ingredients together while they simmer. 🙂
In the blog before the recipe you talk about cheese. I see nothing about cheese in the ingredient list or the instructions. Am I missing something?
Hey Mimi. Some people add grated cheese to the top of their hot goulash. You can use any you like. My son likes it with cheddar. I like just plain. 🙂
wow! My mom used to make a goulash for us when I was little. She passed away when I was 18 and I never learned how she made it, but I remember how it tasted. Over the years I tried to replicate it but always fell short. I believe this recipe could be it! I cannot wait to try it! I will be making it this weekend. Thanks!
I hope it comes close! Let me know 🙂
my grandmother made this, and of course she never wrote down a recipe. It was one of my favorite things that she made. I do remember that hers also had kidney beans in it. I can’t wait to try it!!!
This is the best American Chop Suey I have ever had. So amazing. I halved the recipe but I will be doing the full recipe next time. Oh my god thank you so much for doing this
Hey Angelica! Thanks for such wonderful feedback. You made my day!!! 🙂
My mother used to add a little sugar as her secret ingredient! She was a very good cook and her Banana Bread recipe made it into a cook book!
Hi Carrie! That makes a ton of sense. I often add a pinch or more of sugar to recipes that call for canned tomatoes to cut their acidity. Funny it never occurred to me in this recipe!
Kathleen
My Grandma made this and she would add a ill bit of sugar as well. I have never heard of anyone else doing that until now. I think it’s great! 🙂
I always add sugar to mine as well!
I made this thinking I could freeze some since it makes such a large batch. Oh no, my ‘non-leftover eating’ family ate it all in 2 sittings! Good stuff!!
Hi Julie! Thanks so much for sharing that with me. I’m so happy you liked it! I would freeze the casserole unbaked. I would try and put the casserole in the refrigerator the day before I wanted to serve it the let it sit on the counter at least an hour and bake it. Honestly, not sure how long it will take in the oven. It really will depend on how thawed it is when you put it in the oven. Hope that helps. Sorry I don’t know exactly. I’ll try it soon and let you know 🙂
Kathleen
Make this often..We love it great
Thanks for sharing Patti. We have it often too 🙂
Can you make this in crockpot, letting cook on low for the afternoon? Looking to serve w/garlic bread & tossed salad for a group, but doesn’t say how many servings?
I haven’t done it that way but I bet it could work out well. I’d first brown the meat and then the onion and garlic then add them to the crock pot. Then add the rest of the ingredients except for the pasta for a few hours so all the flavors mingle then add the pasta to cook. This recipe easily feeds 8. I’m assuming there will be other food so i’d guess 10-12 would be more acurrate, obviously depending on the bowl size. Hope it works out well for you. Let me know!
Kathleen
I would be afraid that the macaroni would get soggy and split if it cooked that long!
Hey Dp Girl, ironically my pasta doesn’t split but it does indeed become very soft. Please skip this step if you prefer a more al dente style pasta. I’m just sharing how my family enjoys this 🙂 And yes potatoes sound great!!!
I have made this since college. I always cook the macaroni a couple minutes short of being ‘fully cooked’. Then add it to the finished goulash.
Great idea Maureen!
This recipe turned out amazing!!! Thanks for sharing!!!
So glad you liked it!
I was wondering if you drain the grease from the meat before adding the tomato sauce and other ingredients?
Hi Sara, No I don’t. Feel free to customize the recipe to suit you. It would still be delicious as a lower fat version. You just have to be watchful because you add the veggies and they either need some fat or liquid so they don’t stick, or worse yet, burn. If I was going lower fat I’d cook the meat with a bit of nonstick spray then remove them it a plate when cooked. Then I’d cook the veggies in a little more cooking spray then add a bit of beef broth to prevent sticking as they cook. This is also great with ground turkey!
I always do.
My mom always put some bacon in. Yummy!
My grandma used a bit of bacon, as well. Yummers!
My mom did too
Bacon and cheddar cheese
She cooked the macaroni too.
No bay leaves or soy sauce.
I’m gonna try your way though. Mom didn’t spice or use a lot of herbs.
But hers is good too.
I forgot she would also chop a green pepper!
Sorry
My grandma always added Green bell Pepper as well along with corn & peas. AWESOME>
Instead of using the tomato sauce I use spicy V-8. Just gives it a sight kick because my wife can’t do anything to spicy.
Hi Ricky, the V-8 sounds like an interesting version!
Hi Kathleen,
I’m making your goulash for the first time for Christmas Eve tomorrow night. Got a question for you. The recipe calls for two cans of tomato sauce. Is that 15 ounces total or 15 ounces per can?
Hi Diane. It’s 15 ounces each, total 30 ounces total 🙂
Great recipe, I am sick and my 12 yr. old daughter made this for me tonight!!!! Love it
I am making this at the moment. It smells so awesome in my house! Thank you so much for posting this recipe. My Mom used to make this for us when I was a child and I loved it. Before she passed away, I asked her for the recipe but she couldn’t remember because she had demitia. I really think that this recipe is just like hers, or at least very close. Thank you again! 🙂
I just made this for lunch… and it is amazing!! I just couldn’t wait until tomorrow. Thank you so much for the recipe.
OMG! I thought my mother invented this dish!! Too funny! We didn’t have alot of money and this was always a welcomed dish!
Yeah , Me to. I thought my Dad invented this and made the name up. Lol
You are SO lucky to have such a wonderful
tween! And I bet she was proud to serve you her American Goulash! Nurture her interest in cooking; she may one day have a blog of her own. 🙂
Of the many I have tried this one with longer cooking is sure to create a more refined flavor.
A similar dish my kids make is called Cheeseburger Mac. It is quick to make with what you have on hand and great for young people in first apartments or college I always give it to college kids with a note saying skip Hamburger Helper; this is much better and less expensive!