This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.

This Ina Garten Brownie Pudding is pure chocolate indulgence. The texture is a unique cross between a fudgy brownie and a moist, slightly underbaked chocolate cake. The soft, slightly gooey center begs to be scooped up warm. If you love the thin, crackly crust on a good brownie, you’re going to adore the delicate crust on this brownie pudding. Add vanilla ice cream and let it melt into the chocolate for a dessert you’ll find yourself craving long after the last spoonful.

With everyday ingredients and no frosting or fancy decorating, it’s an easy way to make dessert feel special. Serve it after Sunday dinner, bring it to the holiday table, or make it for the chocolate lover in your life.

For another Ina favorite, try my Ina Garten Brownies. And if you love chocolate cake with a generous layer of fudge sauce underneath, my Chocolate Cobbler belongs on your baking list, too.

Before You Begin

Check your baking dish. Ina calls for a shallow, 2-quart oval baking dish. Capacity matters, but so do the dish’s shape and depth. Two dishes that both hold 8 cups can spread the batter very differently, so don’t assume every 2-quart dish will bake in exactly the same time.
Have your water-bath pan ready. You’ll need a larger baking pan or roasting pan that comfortably holds your pudding dish, with room around it for water.
Tap Water. I add the hottest tap water for the water bath, rather than boiled water. I use a large water pitcher to easily pour it into the large pan.
Start with room-temperature eggs and cooled melted butter. Have these ready before you begin beating the eggs and sugar so the batter comes together smoothly.
Read the doneness section before baking. This dessert needs a different endpoint from regular brownies. Waiting for the center to look fully baked can take away the soft texture you’re trying to achieve.

Ingredients + Key Notes

Unsalted Butter: Melt the butter and let it cool before adding it to the batter. It should still be liquid and easy to pour.

Eggs: Ina’s original recipe calls for extra-large eggs at room temperature. Pay attention to the egg size in the recipe card rather than automatically reaching for large eggs. I used 4 large eggs and 1 large egg yolk with perfect results.

Granulated Sugar: The sugar contributes sweetness and texture. Beat it with the eggs as directed, and resist reducing it casually—changing the amount can change the finished dessert.

Unsweetened Cocoa Powder: Cocoa provides the chocolate flavor here, so choose one you enjoy. Use unsweetened baking cocoa, not hot cocoa mix. Sift it with the flour to remove lumps before adding it to the eggs.

All-Purpose Flour: There’s relatively little flour in this recipe. Measure it carefully by spooning it into your measuring cup and leveling the top.

Salt: Ina doesn’t include salt in her original recipe. I found that ½ teaspoon of fine table salt balances the sweetness and brings out the rich chocolate flavor.

Vanilla: Ina uses the seeds from a vanilla bean. I’ve made it with the originally suggested scraped vanilla bean and also with pure vanilla extract. Frankly, I find the vanilla extract just as flavorful as the vanilla bean scrapings in this recipe.

Framboise Liqueur: This optional raspberry liqueur adds a subtle nuance rather than a strong or even noticeable raspberry flavor. If you don’t have a bottle, don’t feel you need to buy one just for this recipe. The brownie pudding is delicious without it!

Vanilla Ice Cream: The cool, creamy ice cream is a wonderful partner for the rich chocolate and crisp crust. Add it just before serving. Homemade whipped cream works well, too.

🥣 How to Make Ina Garten Brownie Pudding

Prepare the pans. Butter your baking dish and check that it fits inside the larger pan before you start mixing. Preheat the oven as directed in the recipe card.

Melt and cool the butter. Set the melted butter aside while you prepare the remaining ingredients.

Beat the eggs and sugar. Use an electric mixer to beat them until the mixture is very thick and pale yellow. This takes several minutes (7 minutes), so give it time to visibly change rather than stopping once the ingredients are blended.

Sift the dry ingredients. Sift the cocoa powder and flour together, breaking up any cocoa lumps.

Combine gently. With the mixer on low, add the vanilla seeds or vanilla extract, optional framboise, and dry ingredients. Mix just until combined, then slowly pour in the cooled butter. Scrape the bowl to check for unmixed batter.

Set up the water bath. Pour the batter into the buttered dish and place it inside the larger pan. Carefully add very hot tap water to the outer pan until it reaches halfway up the sides of the pudding dish. Keep the water out of the batter.

Bake and check carefully. Follow the recipe card’s timing, then use the crust, edges, and tester check together to assess doneness. The center should remain softer than the outside.

How to Tell When Brownie Pudding Is Done

The most important detail is where you test it. Ina’s directions place the cake tester about 2 inches in from the side of the dish—not in the center.

Look for a formed crust and edges that are more set than the middle. The center underneath should still be soft. Don’t keep baking simply because the middle doesn’t look like a finished brownie.

What Does “Three-Quarters Clean” Mean?

Ina’s description is an approximate visual cue, not something you need to measure. The tester should come out with some chocolate residue remaining.

A tester coated from end to end in loose, wet batter at that testing spot needs more time. A completely clean tester is not the goal.

A few moist crumbs alone don’t tell the whole story. Where you insert the tester matters, and so does the contrast between the set outer portion and the softer center.

Should There Be Chocolate Sauce Underneath?

Expect a soft, fudgy chocolate interior beneath a delicate, crackly crust rather than a separate layer of chocolate sauce. The center is moist and slightly gooey when warm and becomes firmer as it cools. If you’re looking for chocolate cake with a generous layer of fudge sauce underneath, try my Chocolate Cobbler.

Pro Tips

Use the paddle attachment, not the whisk. The paddle gives the eggs enough aeration for that thin brownie crust while keeping the pudding underneath rich and dense. A whisk can incorporate too much air and make the pudding cakier.
Give the eggs and sugar enough mixing time. Look for the thick, pale appearance described in the instructions. This is an important part of the method.
Keep mixing brief once the flour goes in. Combine the batter thoroughly, then stop. Check the bottom and sides of the bowl for any unmixed ingredients.
Use the water bath as directed. It supplies gentler heat around the baking dish, but it doesn’t make the pudding impossible to overbake.
Use the clock and the doneness cues together. Pan shape, batter depth, and oven differences can affect when the dessert reaches the right texture.

Storing + Reheating + Make-Ahead

Storing. Cover leftovers and refrigerate. Store the ice cream separately.

Reheating. Warm individual servings gently in the microwave, checking in short intervals. Stop when the chocolate is warmed through so you don’t continue cooking it unnecessarily.

Making Ahead. Keep the texture change in mind when planning dessert. Freshly baked and warm will give you a different experience from chilled and reheated. For the softest serving, plan your baking around when you want to eat.

Serving Ina Garten Brownie Pudding

Scoop the warm brownie pudding into small bowls, making sure each serving gets some crisp crust and soft chocolate underneath. Add vanilla ice cream just before taking it to the table.

Fresh berries are lovely alongside it, but this dessert doesn’t need much dressing up. Warm chocolate and melting vanilla ice cream do the work beautifully.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why Did My Brownie Pudding Bake Up Too Firm?

It may have baked beyond the soft-center stage. A different dish or a hotter-than-expected oven can also affect the result.

Check the pudding at the location specified in the instructions, and avoid waiting for the center to look fully set. Also consider its serving temperature: cooled brownie pudding is naturally firmer than warm brownie pudding.

Why Is the Center Still Soft?

A soft center is part of this dessert’s intended texture. Assess it alongside the crust, more-set edges, and tester result about 2 inches from the side. Soft and pudding-like is the goal; loose batter throughout the dish is a different result.

Can I Skip the Water Bath?

I recommend keeping it. The water bath is part of Ina’s method for achieving the contrast between the baked exterior and soft interior. Baking without it changes the conditions, so the same timing and result shouldn’t be assumed.

Can I Use a Different Baking Dish?

A substitute needs to fit comfortably inside your water-bath pan and hold the batter at an appropriate depth. Matching capacity alone doesn’t guarantee the same result.

A wider dish spreads the batter more thinly, while a smaller, deeper dish changes how the middle cooks. Follow the tested dish recommendation in the recipe card whenever possible.

Do I Need the Raspberry Liqueur?

No. Framboise is optional in Ina’s original recipe, so you can omit it.

Is Brownie Pudding Best Warm or Cold?

I prefer serving it warm for the contrast between the soft chocolate, crisp crust, and cold ice cream. As it cools, the interior becomes denser and firmer.

More Chocolate Desserts to Love

Best Chocolate Cake — Rich, moist, and made for birthdays, celebrations, or satisfying a serious chocolate craving.

Fudge Cake — Deep chocolate flavor and rich, fudgy frosting make this cake a chocolate lover’s dream.

Fudgy Zucchini Brownies — Dense, rich brownies for anyone who always reaches for the fudgiest piece.

Chocolate Bundt Cake — Ultra moist and topped with chocolate ganache, this easy cake starts with a mix!

Brownie Cookies — All the chocolate satisfaction of a brownie in an irresistible cookie.

Chocolate Crinkle Cookies — Rich, flourless chocolate cookies with snowy powdered sugar tops and those beautiful signature cracks.

Want More Recipes Like This?

If you love comforting, tried-and-true recipes, subscribe to my newsletter, and I’ll send my newest recipes, easy dinner ideas, and old-fashioned favorites straight to your inbox. It’s free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Tried This Recipe?

I’d love to hear how your Ina Garten Brownie Pudding turned out! Leave a comment below and a star rating to share your experience—it helps other readers and means so much to me.

If you make this recipe, snap a photo and tag @gonna_want_seconds on Instagram. I always love seeing what you’re cooking in your kitchen!

Thanks for stopping by my kitchen today — happy cooking, friends! ❤️