Classic Pumpkin Pie

Classic Pumpkin Pie

I’ve been making this version of pumpkin pie for sooo long I have absolutely no idea where I originally got the recipe.  I have it written on a little recipe card that is more than a little tattered and stained but, obviously, well love!  In the past, I have tried different pumpkin pie recipes just to make sure I had found THE one for me.  I have to tell you, this one is, hands down,  my all-time favorite.  It is the perfect classic pumpkin pie for me and my family.  If you are looking for THE one for you, give this classic a try.  Enjoy!

21 Responses to Classic Pumpkin Pie

  1. Karine

    Your pumpkin pie recipe sounds delicious! Thanks for sharing 🙂

  2. Coleen's Recipes

    I've been making the pumpkin pie recipe on the Libby's can for my entire cooking life. You really have thrown me a pumpkin pie curve with your recipe…haha…I'll bet the molasses gives the pie a wonderful flavor. I think I'm going to have to give this a trial run tomorrow!! Thank you.

  3. HoneyB

    I've never seen molasses either but I'm betting it is good! Can't wait to see the photo!

  4. Rosabela

    This sounds soooo good! I have never heard of a pumpkin pie that calls for molasses – it definitely makes it unique. I know molasses is available in Germany but I have yet to find it. Can't wait to see the photo!!

  5. Nat

    Sounds like a great Pumpkin Pie…can't wait for the pics : ) !

  6. teresa

    this is just lovely! it wouldn't be the holidays without a clasic like this!

  7. Katy ~

    I make the recipe on the back of the One Pie pumpkin can, a product that's only available here in New England. It's what we used while I was growing up, it's what I use now. Tried the Libby's because of all the hype, and both my BF and I said, “oh no!” Talk about food traditions, grins. Your recipe is very very similar so I know it's super good!

  8. Xiaolu

    This comment has been removed by the author.

  9. Xiaolu

    Yum! I love pumpkin pie, it's definitely one of my favorites. I don't have a favorite recipe yet, so I may have to try yours!

  10. the twins

    i love pumpkin pie but i've never made it. yours looks like a great recipe to try!

  11. danazia

    I will have to try it! Thanks for sharing.

  12. Curt

    My absolute favorite pie. I never miss an opportunity for pumpkin pie this time of year.

    I'll have to try this one and see how it measures up!

  13. Kiran @

    I am gonna try baking my first pie ever this year. So excited. That definitely looks delish!

  14. Pingback: Fall Bucket List for the Whole Family!

  15. Pingback: October 12 – National Pumpkin Pie Day

  16. Pingback: 20 Reasons Why Fall is Amazing - made with HAPPY

  17. Pingback: Preparing for Thanksgiving: Desserts (with recipes)

  18. Pingback: 57 Easy Homemade Pumpkin Pie Ideas For The Holidays - Pie Addict

  19. Pingback: A Thanksgiving of Pies and Petting Zoos | Bella, Books, and Baking

  20. Flo Valdes

    This recipe was absolutely delicious!!! It was a big hit for Thanksgiving! I plan on making it for Christmas as well! Thanks for sharing

    • Kathleen

      Hi Flo. Yay! So glad you enjoyed 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *