This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.
Why Is Indiana Known for Sugar Cream Pie?
Old-fashioned sugar cream pie is often called Hoosier Pie or Indiana sugar cream pie, and it has deep roots in the state’s history. It was likely brought to Indiana by Amish and Quaker communities in the early 1800s and quickly became a staple in farm kitchens.
Because it’s made with simple pantry ingredients — cream, sugar, and a thickener — it earned the nickname “desperation pie.” These were the kinds of desserts you could make without fresh fruit or expensive ingredients, which made them especially popular during hard times.
Today, sugar cream pie is considered the unofficial state pie of Indiana and is still a beloved classic across the Midwest. And once you taste that rich, buttery, silky filling with its lightly caramelized top, it’s easy to see why it’s stood the test of time.
Why This Sugar Cream Pie Recipe Works
- Perfectly set filling: The cornstarch thickens the custard just enough to create clean slices without being stiff or gummy.
- Rich, velvety texture: Heavy cream gives this pie its signature silky, melt-in-your-mouth consistency.
- Simple, reliable method: No eggs, no complicated steps — just a straightforward process that delivers consistent results every time.
- Classic cinnamon sugar topping: Adds warmth, flavor, and that lightly caramelized finish that makes this pie unforgettable.
- Sugar cream pie is a rich, old-fashioned custard-style pie made with cream, sugar, and a starch thickener — known for its smooth, silky texture and caramelized top.
Why Sugar Cream Pie Sets (and Doesn’t Turn Runny)
Sugar cream pie is a starch-thickened custard, not an egg-based one. That means the cornstarch has to fully activate on the stovetop before the pie ever goes into the crust. As it heats, the starch absorbs liquid and thickens the filling into that smooth, sliceable texture.
Once baked and cooled, the filling continues to firm up as it chills. If it’s undercooked or sliced too soon, it can seem runny — but when done right, it sets into a rich, silky filling that holds its shape beautifully.
Sugar Cream Pie Ingredients + Key Notes
- Baked Pie Shell: I generally buy a flat, prepared pie crust for convenience. Lightly flour your counter and roll it out to fit your pie pan.
- Cornstarch: This is the key thickener in the filling since this pie doesn’t use eggs. It’s what gives the pie that smooth, sliceable texture.
- Sugar: Granulated sugar sweetens the filling and helps create that classic, lightly caramelized flavor.
- Salt: Just a small amount enhances the sweetness and balances the overall flavor.
- Melted Butter: I use unsalted butter to control the salt level. It adds richness and depth to the filling.
- Heavy Cream: No substitutes here — heavy cream is essential for that ultra-creamy, velvety texture this pie is known for.
- Vanilla Extract: Pure vanilla gives the filling a warm, rounded flavor that really makes everything pop.
- Cinnamon + Nutmeg: A light sprinkle over the top adds warmth, aroma, and that signature finish.
🥣 How To Make Sugar Cream Pie
Here’s a quick look at how to make this easy sugar cream pie (full instructions in the recipe card below):
Prepare the crust. Start by rolling out your pie dough and fitting it into a 9-inch pie dish. Blind bake it until lightly golden, then set it aside to cool completely. This gives you a sturdy base so the filling sets up beautifully without getting soggy.
Make the filling. In a saucepan, whisk together the sugar, cornstarch, and salt. Slowly add the heavy cream and butter, stirring to combine. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until the mixture thickens and comes to a gentle boil. You’re looking for a smooth, thick consistency that coats the back of a spoon.
Finish and assemble. Remove the pan from the heat and stir in the vanilla. Pour the filling into your cooled crust and use a spatula to smooth the top. Sprinkle with cinnamon and nutmeg, then place it briefly under the broiler to create that classic lightly caramelized finish.
Cool and set. Let the pie cool completely at room temperature, then refrigerate for a few hours (or overnight) so it fully sets. This step is key for getting clean slices and that perfectly creamy texture.
⭐ Pro Tips
⭐ Use a Metal Pie Plate for Blind Baking
Even though my photos may show otherwise, I prefer a metal pie plate whenever I blind bake a crust. It heats more evenly, helps the bottom bake up nicely, and can go from the freezer straight into the oven without the risk of cracking or shattering like some glass or ceramic dishes.
⭐ No Pie Weights? No Problem
If you don’t have ceramic pie weights, dried beans or uncooked rice work just fine. The goal is simply to keep the crust from puffing up or sliding down while it bakes, so use whatever you have on hand.
⭐ Cook the Filling Until It’s Truly Thick
One of the biggest mistakes with sugar cream pie is pulling the filling off the heat too soon. It should be thick enough to coat the back of a spoon and drip off slowly. If it still looks thin or pours like liquid, keep cooking.
⭐ Let the Pie Chill Before Slicing
This pie needs time to fully set. For the cleanest slices and the best texture, let it cool completely, then refrigerate it for a few hours or overnight before serving. That rest time makes a big difference.
Storing + Reheating + Freezing + Make-Ahead Tips
Storing
Store sugar cream pie covered in the refrigerator for up to 3–4 days. Because this is a cream-based pie, it should not be left out at room temperature for extended periods. The texture actually improves after chilling, making it even more smooth and sliceable the next day.
Reheating
This pie is best served cold or at room temperature, so reheating isn’t necessary. If you prefer it slightly warmer, let it sit at room temperature for 20–30 minutes before serving.
Freezing
Freezing is not recommended. The creamy filling can separate and become watery once thawed, which affects both texture and appearance.
Make-Ahead
This is a perfect make-ahead dessert. In fact, it’s even better after it’s had time to chill and fully set. For best results, make it the day before serving and refrigerate overnight.
Why Is My Sugar Cream Pie Runny?
If your pie doesn’t set beautifully, it usually comes down to one of these common issues:
- The filling didn’t cook long enough: The cornstarch needs to fully activate on the stovetop before baking. The mixture should be thick enough to coat the back of a spoon and drip off slowly — not pour like liquid.
- It was overworked: Stirring too aggressively or for too long can break down the cornstarch, preventing it from thickening properly.
- It didn’t have time to set: This pie continues to firm up as it cools. Cutting into it too soon is one of the most common reasons it looks runny.
- Old cornstarch: Cornstarch loses effectiveness over time, which can impact how well the filling sets.
If you follow the method in this recipe and give the pie time to fully cool and chill, you’ll end up with a smooth, creamy filling that slices cleanly every time. 💗
How Do I Know When Sugar Cream Pie Is Done and Set?
The filling should be thick on the stovetop before it ever goes into the crust — it should coat the back of a spoon and hold its shape. After baking, the pie should look set around the edges with just a slight jiggle in the center. It will continue to firm up as it cools and chills.
More Pie Recipes You’ll Love
After you’ve made this hoosier sugar cream pie, here’s a list of more delicious pies!
- Chocolate Pudding Pie – Silky, rich, and deeply chocolatey with that classic old-fashioned pudding pie texture.
- Chess Pie – A Southern classic with a buttery, sweet filling and a delicate crackly top.
- Buttermilk Pie – Smooth, creamy, and lightly tangy with the same cozy old-fashioned appeal.
- Sweet Potato Pie with Condensed Milk – Velvety, warmly spiced, and perfect for holiday tables.
- Lemon Icebox Pie – Cool, creamy, and bright with a refreshing citrus finish.
- Fig Pie – A nostalgic Southern favorite with rich, jammy flavor and plenty of old-fashioned charm.
Tried This Recipe?
Don’t forget to subscribe to my Free Newsletter so you never miss a new recipe. From cozy comfort food to nostalgic desserts, there’s always something delicious coming your way!
If you made this sugar cream pie, I’d love to hear what you think! 💗 Please leave a review and a ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ star rating and let me know how it turned out — your feedback means so much and helps other readers, too.
Tip for mobile readers: scroll just a bit to tap the stars — thank you!
💬 Which one are you making first — this pie or one of the others? Hit reply and tell me!
Thanks for stopping by my kitchen today — happy cooking, friends! Kathleen 💗
Sugar Cream Pie
Ingredients
Crust:
- 1 (9-inch) pre-baked deep dish pastry pie crust
Pie Filling:
- 5 tablespoons cornstarch
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- pinch salt
- 5 tablespoons butter
- 3 cups heavy cream
- 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
Topping:
- 2 tablespoons butter, melted
- 2 tablespoons sugar
- 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
Instructions
Prepare Crust:
- Prepare and bake a 9-inch deep dish pie crust. Blind bake and cool.
- Wrap a pie shield around edge of crust.
Prepare Pie Filling:
- In a heavy bottom, medium-sized saucepan add the cornstarch (5 tablespoons), sugar (1 cup), and salt (a pinch). Whisk together. Pour in the cream (3 cups) and add butter (5 tablespoons). Heat over medium-low heat, whisking continually to prevent burning or scorching. Bring to a boil and cook for 1 minute.
- Remove pan from burner and stir in vanilla (1 tablespoon).
- Pour filling into blind baked pie crust. Smooth top with a small offset spatula. Allow pie to set for 20-30 minutes.
- Adjust the oven rack to approximately 6 inches from the heating element. Set oven to broil.
Prepare topping:
- Pour melted butter (2 tablespoons) evenly over the top of the pie. Tilt the pie side to side, as necessary to distribute butter evenly over the top of the pie.
- In a small bowl, whisk together sugar (2 tablespoons), cinnamon (1 teaspoon), and nutmeg (1/4 teaspoon).
- Sprinkle the spice mixture evenly over the butter. Broil on the adjusted oven rack for 1-2 minutes, until the sugar crystallizes and browns. Watch carefully so the topping doesn't burn!
- Place pie on a wire backing rack and cool completely. Refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours, or best overnight.
Notes
- Use a Metal Pie Plate for Blind Baking. Even though my photos may show otherwise, I prefer a metal pie plate whenever I blind bake a crust. It heats more evenly, helps the bottom bake up nicely, and can go from the freezer straight into the oven without the risk of cracking or shattering like some glass or ceramic dishes.
- No Pie Weights? No Problem. If you don’t have ceramic pie weights, dried beans or uncooked rice work just fine. The goal is simply to keep the crust from puffing up or sliding down while it bakes, so use whatever you have on hand.
- Cook the Filling Until It’s Truly Thick. One of the biggest mistakes with sugar cream pie is pulling the filling off the heat too soon. It should be thick enough to coat the back of a spoon and drip off slowly. If it still looks thin or pours like liquid, keep cooking.
- Let the Pie Chill Before Slicing. This pie needs time to fully set. For the cleanest slices and the best texture, let it cool completely, then refrigerate it for a few hours or overnight before serving. That rest time makes a big difference.
Nutrition
I really saved some slices and placed it at the very back of my fridge all just for me! LOL. It’s soooo good!
OMG, I won’t tell anyone. Hahaha! Thanks, Anne! I’m glad you enjoyed and saved some 😀